Guitar Hero
One of the nice things about the Shoreline is that there are things to see and do before the concert starts. If you’re a world class anal-retentive like me, and God help you if you are, you often arrive much too early for meetings and events. Take a stroll at the Shoreline and you can find a wall of pictures from previous concerts, three or four places to go to the bathroom, a dozen places to get a bite to eat and about a thousand places to buy alcohol.
One of the booths there had a video game set-up. I walked up to it and watched as two kids played Guitar Hero. I had heard of the game, but had never seen it live. It’s a remarkable piece of technology that allows the player to feel as if he is playing electric guitar simply by pressing the appropriate color button when it is shown on the screen. You don’t need any guitar playing ability when you begin, and you won’t have acquired any when you’re done.
And that’s the knock on Guitar Hero. The kids are having a grand old time and then some grumpy old fart like, uh, I don’t know, well, me, walks by and can’t resist commenting that these kids are wasting all this time and not coming any closer to learning to play the guitar.
I continued on my walk to the end of the strip, turned around and stopped again at the Guitar Hero booth. Just as I arrived some guy very close to my own age muttered, “Everybody’s playing that and nobody’s learning how to really play the guitar.” How exciting! I had randomly come across a fellow grumpy old fart!
And I knew then that he was wrong. Guitar Hero is not an alternative way to learn a musical instrument. It’s a video game, plain and simple. If it didn’t exist those two pimply goofballs wouldn’t be taking guitar lessons instead. They’d be playing World of Warcraft, or some other nonsense. Those who want to play guitar are doing just that, while those who prefer video games are playing video games.
Still, here’s what bothers me. I play guitar. In fact I have been doing so regularly for 37 years. And there is one thing that has remained absolutely consistent over all that time: I’m terrible. You can’t imagine how disheartening it is for me to see some 17-year old in a band already playing better than I ever will. No worry, I’ve learned to accept it.
But these kids playing Guitar Hero have no idea how to play guitar. Which is fine. Still, I believe that if they are not going to make the effort to learn the instrument then they are not entitled to the benefits. They have no right to stand there with the fake guitars hung over their shoulders, hips cocked and hair hanging in their eyes.
It’s the cool guitar-playing pose and it must be earned. Clapton has earned it. Townsend has earned it. Even the guitarist in Journey, whoever he might be this week, has earned it. But not these pretentious posers who wouldn’t know an A-chord from a bungee cord. So play all the Guitar Hero you want, Kids, but please, only use the uncool postures.


