Jumping Off The Tallahatchee Bridge

Those of you who are old enough remember that the song told the story of Billie Joe McCallister committing suicide by jumping of the Tallahatchee Bridge. During the song it is also revealed that Billie Joe and the female narrator had recently been seen throwing “something” off that same bridge. What they were throwing off and why Billie Joe killed himself is never revealed, but forty years ago there was plenty of discussion about it, let me tell you boy howdy.
Nine years after the song was recorded a movie called Ode to Billy Joe was released (And if you’re thinking that I spelled “Billy” wrong in the movie title you’re absolutely wrong and I’m right. As usual.) to help clear up some of the mystery. In the movie it turns out that Billy Joe threw the narrator’s rag doll off the bridge, and then threw himself off because of a failed homosexual affair. (Or as Billy Joe himself might have said, “They don’t call me B.J. for nothing.)
Whatever Bobbie Gentry had in mind when she wrote the song, it sure as hell wasn’t that! In fact from the beginning Gentry has always insisted that the point of the song was how unfeeling the family was around the dinner table regarding the death, especially in light of the fact that Billie Joe was the boyfriend of a family member. When asked about the song again at the time of the movie’s release Bobbie Gentry admitted that she had no idea why Billie Joe killed himself.
Ah but what was that mystery object that was so carelessly tossed off the bridge? Again, Bobbie Gentry doesn’t know or isn’t saying. It wasn’t meant to be the focus of the story. Yet some of the speculation turned out to be a lot of fun. I remember a comedy show at the time (Yeah, I can remember forty year old TV skits but not what I had for lunch. Go figure.) where a man was being threatened with a gun. He yelled, “Please don’t shoot, I’ll tell you anything you want to know. I’ll even tell you what Billie Joe threw off the Tallahatchee Bridge!” Sure, it doesn’t mean much now but trust me it got major yuks in the olden days.
In addition to the aforementioned rag-doll there was speculation that Billie Joe and his girlfriend were throwing drugs off the bridge. This of course would undoubtedly lead to BJ’s subsequent suicide. This theory was obviously created by some anti-drug organization that predated DARE and those other spoilsports. Another theory was that BJ and his girl were throwing their newborn illegitimate baby into the river, and the suicide was because of BJ’s guilt over this act.
I flipped the first time I heard this one. I love this theory, even though it’s obviously wrong. I think if this were the real meaning behind the vague lyrics it would have made the song twice as good as it already was. In fact if I had written the song I would have admitted (after the debates had died down and all the money was in, of course) that yes, this was indeed the meaning of the song. A baby! Priceless!
So do you remember the song? The movie? If this song came out today, what do you think that Billie Joe and his girlfriend would be throwing off the Tallahatchee Bridge? A typewriter? Oprah? An iPod filled with Bobbie Gentry songs? Come on, use your imagination and let’s have some fun!












